Yes I too have been so frustrated I quit playing for awhile. 12 of 13 fails. My bow at 0 after getting to 6 and resetting 4 times to 0. Fails should at least b a 50/50 shot. Resets maybe 10-20. Also have gotten 1 inferno drop since Xmas. I have over 130 aqua however. COME-ON combination of both Will cause me to cease play if continues!
Im half and half, personally, i would prefer that if you failed your enhancement it would just stay at the same already aquired level instead or drop down/reset my Aureate bracer, has rest to 0 every time i try lvl 8 so i feel your pain, and support your proposal but with a different view
A friend of mine recently quit(after2-3yrs)because of this very problem, something does need to be done...not necessarily 100% success, but certainly a higher rate than is current, or at very least no drop in lvl after fails.
In my experience enchanting, the success rate is maybe 1 success in 20 attempts. (If I'm lucky) As bad as it is already just trying to get the equip and elements, a change is definitely needed. Especially considering equip can reset to 0, and the cost of enchanting is already ridiculous. My suggestions: Enchanting any lvl 0 to lvl1 should never fail. Aqua / inferno should drop from all EB's. Resets should either be eliminated or capped. (1 possible reset per piece) Could consider a % for fail rates. Lvl 0= 100% chance of success. Level 10 = 10% chance, etc. The game is growing faster than a lot of us can keep up with. Please give us a break before you lose more ppl getting frustrated over things like this.
I have already written a thread regarding a way to get equipment enchanted with ease "potential idea for a new mithril spell" at the tail end of last year that kaw admin commented on and said nice idea so hopefully they may implement a version of what I suggested. It was basically a spell called master mage, it would cost around 50-75 mithril and would give between 3-5 100% successful enchants on any equipment you choose to enchant wit the spell active.