IlBlLIAIClKlISIMlOlKlEIl
Active Member
Re: The Return of Chaos Wars
It's great that chaos wars are returning. Hopefully the devs will use this series of wars to actually improve things as opposed to the blunderfest that was season 3. I realize this is probably anathema to most who war regularly but I really believe that we haven't been able to determine whether the new matching system works. With the rosters being stacked sky high with either ps/sh (I counted 1 war where upwards of 90% of clans had extensive sh/ps) this becomes a chicken and egg scenario where is it the stacking that is causing so many bad matches or vice versa.
I had several suggestions from times past, all completely ignored naturally, which could help eliminate some of the stacking going on.
1. Solving PS: All kingdoms going to war must include at least 1 spy and 1 soldier building. This takes care of the ps problem entirely.
2. Possible fix for SH: what I call the alternative minimum tax approach. During EE only, when you attack another kingdom, your plunder will be the greater of 1) your normal plunder or 2) the amount of plunder that the defender would receive had they successfully attacked you. This AMT plunder would factor in all aspects including whether your kingdom uses def pots, current soldier levels of the defender, etc.
I don't believe that coding these ideas would be difficult but they would give at least a ray of hope for decent mids to make a comeback to war where now they have none.
I had a couple other ideas that I believe would be great additions to war but they aren't focused on eliminating the stacking issues:
1) scouting in EE uses sdp. Go hansels and hopefully that removes the sting of my first suggestion.
2) standardize the purchase price of mith for kingdoms of all sizes - say 1B/mith. This would help to balance out payouts.
It's great that chaos wars are returning. Hopefully the devs will use this series of wars to actually improve things as opposed to the blunderfest that was season 3. I realize this is probably anathema to most who war regularly but I really believe that we haven't been able to determine whether the new matching system works. With the rosters being stacked sky high with either ps/sh (I counted 1 war where upwards of 90% of clans had extensive sh/ps) this becomes a chicken and egg scenario where is it the stacking that is causing so many bad matches or vice versa.
I had several suggestions from times past, all completely ignored naturally, which could help eliminate some of the stacking going on.
1. Solving PS: All kingdoms going to war must include at least 1 spy and 1 soldier building. This takes care of the ps problem entirely.
2. Possible fix for SH: what I call the alternative minimum tax approach. During EE only, when you attack another kingdom, your plunder will be the greater of 1) your normal plunder or 2) the amount of plunder that the defender would receive had they successfully attacked you. This AMT plunder would factor in all aspects including whether your kingdom uses def pots, current soldier levels of the defender, etc.
I don't believe that coding these ideas would be difficult but they would give at least a ray of hope for decent mids to make a comeback to war where now they have none.
I had a couple other ideas that I believe would be great additions to war but they aren't focused on eliminating the stacking issues:
1) scouting in EE uses sdp. Go hansels and hopefully that removes the sting of my first suggestion.
2) standardize the purchase price of mith for kingdoms of all sizes - say 1B/mith. This would help to balance out payouts.