Derailed. /lock

O_o_____Frog____o_0 said:
WoIfie said:
Well obviously if people are derailing the topic then op didnt do a good job in making a fun thread.


Sure blame the OP. You probably also think women who are assaulted are asking for it cause their skirts are too short.

Remember derailing is not the same as trolling. You can argue the OP's point and still troll his thinking on a topic, but derailing is bringing up unrelated stuff or topics to change the whole focus of the thread. If the troll ignores the content but begins a character assault on the OP, the troll could be banned.

This dude is always linking stuff that is totally unrelated.
 
O_o_____Frog____o_0 said:
Also if you think a thread is badly written, there is always the option of closing it and not post anything. No reason to derail, I believe.

Wow. The hypocrisy. I lost count of the times hes criticized my spelling yet he continuously posts in ma threads :lol:
 
O_o_____Frog____o_0 said:
WoIfie said:
If people need to change the topic of the thread than people obviously didn't like the original topic. Hence the derailing


Not that obvious in my mind. Sometimes it's done out of pure hatred for the OP.

So frog hates me? Is that y he derails my threads?
 
Rikkimaru said:
-AppleGirl- said:
I actually have a question about locked threads

Do they get graveyarded at some point ? I've tried to search for a few that were locked and they're completely gone.

Or is the graveyarding done arbitrarily ?
I believe that locked threads have a TTL on them once locked, unless they're in best of.

All threads have a death sentence at some point, wether they are locked or not, go n look yourself on how far back you can look in active topics. But best off topics sticky threads remain forever.
 
PeanutButterWithJellyTime said:
The word "derail" is so open to interpretation it's insane. We need a better word.
de·rail
/dēˈrāl/

verb
  • cause (a train or trolley car) to leave its tracks accidentally.
    "a train was derailed after it collided with a herd of cattle"
    • (of a train or trolley car) accidentally leave the tracks.
      "the trolley cars had a tendency to derail on sharp corners"
    • obstruct (a process) by diverting it from its intended course.
      "the plot is seen by some as an attempt to derail the negotiations"
 
Surely locking the thread is like permenantly closing a cinema where a shooting took place...
It just seems a bit unfair...
I feel like the derailer should get a warning (unless they're a major douchebag, in which case silence).
 
Jonathan07 said:
Surely locking the thread is like permenantly closing a cinema where a shooting took place...
It just seems a bit unfair...
I feel like the derailer should get a warning (unless they're a major ​, in which case silence).

Is more like canceling the projection of a movie because someone was noisy in the theatre.
 
IIIVladIII said:
Jonathan07 said:
Surely locking the thread is like permenantly closing a cinema where a shooting took place...
It just seems a bit unfair...
I feel like the derailer should get a warning (unless they're a major ​, in which case silence).

Is more like canceling the projection of a movie because someone was noisy in the theatre.

Perfect analogy!
 
Can't punish the author or I'll bring back the derail train like I did a long time ago.

People deliberately derailing threads, needlessly quoting, double and triple posts should be silenced not unlike in game imho.
 
Imitation-Cheese said:
The way i see it is this:

Locking a derailed thread is like a cop showing up to a beating in progress. But rather than arrest the people doing the beating, they arrest the person being beaten.

Frankly, it is my opinion that no matter what the content of the OP is or who that person is, it should never be OK to punish a victim or blame them for the actions of others.

I mean, can you imagine a bunch of guys showing up for court and looking at the judge and telling him that the reason they jumped the kid is because he talked weird or looks funny? You think the judge would be all "Oh, he didnt defend himself and he had the balls to walk down the street wearing an orange hat with a green bill? Oh yeah, he deserved a beating. You guys are free to go. Orange hat guy - stay off my streets and get outta my courthouse."

That is a far-reaching analogy based on a mod-as-protagonist perspective, yet fails to incorporate the full meaning of the OP-as-Victim paradigm you appear to operate under.

This is a game, and these are forums. There are players, and volunteers. No one is actually being beaten. To compare a thread lock on a role-playing game to being beaten up in RL is ridiculous.

Generally, if the situation is OP vs One Hater, the thread can be 'cleaned' by mods merging the offending posts out, and building an evidence file, which may result in a ban (depending on the severity and context of what was said).

If it is the OP vs the World, then its a different issue. If the comments are most of the people bashing OP, then yes I agree the OP is the victim. When we have players who are very disliked (not to name name's), the response to their threads are usually negative and spiral into haterade.

In OPvW, the thread is normally beyond being saved by a 'clean.' To protect the victim, we lock the thread so that the harassment against the OP stops. To use your same analogy, this is the equivalent of your police officer stopping the bashing.

If the harassing posts are also in breach of TOU, bans may occur. I am yet to be party to mass-bans over derailing, but I also can't see the ban history. The forum community in KaW is very mature, and most know where the line is when it comes to harassing those they dislike.

When it comes to bans in forums, we try and do a 'less-is-more approach' so that people do not feel like forums are being over-policed. However, if you feel forums is under-policed, then this is definitely something that I can have support look into regarding the moderator action process.

Hope that clarifies the process.
 
Daphnia said:
If it is the OP vs the World, then its a different issue. If the comments are most of the people bashing OP, then yes I agree the OP is the victim. When we have players who are very disliked (not to name name's), the response to their threads are usually negative and spiral into haterade.

In OPvW, the thread is normally beyond being saved by a 'clean.' To protect the victim, we lock the thread so that the harassment against the OP stops. To use your same analogy, this is the equivalent of your police officer stopping the bashing.

First of all, thanks for having the tenacity to respond publicly and thanks for your service to the kawmmunity.

Second, I'm picking out the part of your post that concerns me.

While I agree that my analogy may have been extreme, I hope you can agree that the same principles apply.

However, what I'm getting from this part of your response is that violating the ToU by derailing a thread is OK, but only if many other people are actively violating the ToU by derailing the thread together with some arbitrary number of other offenders?

Don't you think this encourages mob mentality? As long as we all get together and jump this guy, the mods won't touch us?

A lot of people dislike black people. Does that make it OK for other people to ostracise them as long as a bunch of people do it together?

I understand that cleaning threads with lots of derailers is a lot of work, but I think when bans start getting handed down for violating the ToU by derailing, people will get the message and the problem might go away...
 
Daphnia said:
Imitation-Cheese said:
The way i see it is this:

Locking a derailed thread is like a cop showing up to a beating in progress. But rather than arrest the people doing the beating, they arrest the person being beaten.

Frankly, it is my opinion that no matter what the content of the OP is or who that person is, it should never be OK to punish a victim or blame them for the actions of others.

I mean, can you imagine a bunch of guys showing up for court and looking at the judge and telling him that the reason they jumped the kid is because he talked weird or looks funny? You think the judge would be all "Oh, he didnt defend himself and he had the balls to walk down the street wearing an orange hat with a green bill? Oh yeah, he deserved a beating. You guys are free to go. Orange hat guy - stay off my streets and get outta my courthouse."

That is a far-reaching analogy based on a mod-as-protagonist perspective, yet fails to incorporate the full meaning of the OP-as-Victim paradigm you appear to operate under.

This is a game, and these are forums. There are players, and volunteers. No one is actually being beaten. To compare a thread lock on a role-playing game to being beaten up in RL is ridiculous.

Generally, if the situation is OP vs One Hater, the thread can be 'cleaned' by mods merging the offending posts out, and building an evidence file, which may result in a ban (depending on the severity and context of what was said).

If it is the OP vs the World, then its a different issue. If the comments are most of the people bashing OP, then yes I agree the OP is the victim. When we have players who are very disliked (not to name name's), the response to their threads are usually negative and spiral into haterade.

In OPvW, the thread is normally beyond being saved by a 'clean.' To protect the victim, we lock the thread so that the harassment against the OP stops. To use your same analogy, this is the equivalent of your police officer stopping the bashing.

If the harassing posts are also in breach of TOU, bans may occur. I am yet to be party to mass-bans over derailing, but I also can't see the ban history. The forum community in KaW is very mature, and most know where the line is when it comes to harassing those they dislike.

When it comes to bans in forums, we try and do a 'less-is-more approach' so that people do not feel like forums are being over-policed. However, if you feel forums is under-policed, then this is definitely something that I can have support look into regarding the moderator action process.

Hope that clarifies the process.
Fancy writing a essay jesus christ
 
Daphnia had to write that for the wanna be creative writing crybabys like cheese.He wants to post threads on a RP game with a 9 plus rating and them taken serious with only debate or positive feedback.Any little bit if flamming or trolling ruins his kaw experience because he doesn't play the tap tap competitive side only the social/forum side..
 
Cheese wastes his life inside his house cuz hes afraid of the system. He corroborates his point of view by searchin for and keeping newspaper articles that are either biased or exaggerate the truth so he can preach to ppl on the internet how right he is.

Police state is one of his big words. He shouts this words left and right. He'll be afraid of and compare any civilized order figure to terrorist figure.

He does this because he's weak and afraid. He compensate by trying to be an intellectual.

You got to try harder. I can see through your pathetic rhetoric.

If people were to agree in your stupid, baseless,fear-based arguments we would be set 500 years back. Yeah, exactly the place you'd like so you could deny about half the population their rights.

Daphnia is not by any means any of your stupid characters in your little fantasy world of fear and represion. Back off you imbecile.

Pd.- you know what rights I'm talking about. Don't waste your time pretending you don't know.
 
Back
Top