Concerning Chests, freebies, in game purchasing....

This doesn't just apply to "chests" but anything that can be used as "currency" (per se) that you can purchase through in game purchasing with RL money and applies to any aspect of the game that gives you an advantage in game play ....not relevant in every country. Great Britain & USA not regulated at all and prob won't ever be. Especially in USA, not sure about GB. it's highly regulated in countries like Belgium and South Korea. Anything that turns into law in Belgium has a likely hood of going EU wide. This is an ongoing evolving issue, so ild imagine that ALL game developers are aware of this and proceed with the game development concerning "rewards" with caution...

....the more you know 





In video games, a loot box (sometimes loot crate or prize crate, among other names) is a consumable virtual item which can be redeemed to receive a randomised selection of further virtual items, ranging from simple customization options for a player's avatar or character, to game-changing equipment such as weapons and armor. A loot box is typically a form of monetisation, with players either buying the boxes directly or receiving the boxes during play and later buying "keys" with which to redeem them. These systems may also be known as gacha (based on gashapon - capsule toys) and integrated into gacha games.
Loot box concepts originated from loot systems in massively multiplayer online role-playing games, and from the monetisation of free-to-play mobile gaming. They first appeared around 2007 to 2010, but since then, appear in many free-to-play games and in some full-priced titles. Loot box systems were made highly visible through the popularity of Overwatch (2016), but several games that followed in 2017 expanded approaches to loot boxes that caused loot box systems to be highly criticised by the second half of 2017, in particular Star Wars Battlefront II.
Loot boxes are regulated under gambling law in China, Japan, Australia, The Netherlands, Belgium, and the Isle of Man. They are the subject of investigations by the gambling regulators of several more countries. They have been criticised as being anti-consumer when implemented in full-priced games. They are a common source of the virtual items used in skin gambling.
 
XIXXIIX_monkey-poo_IXIIXXI said:
This doesn't just apply to "chests" but anything that can be used as "currency" (per se) that you can purchase through in game purchasing with RL money and applies to any aspect of the game that gives you an advantage in game play ....not relevant in every country. Great Britain & USA not regulated at all and prob won't ever be. Especially in USA, not sure about GB. it's highly regulated in countries like Belgium and South Korea. Anything that turns into law in Belgium has a likely hood of going EU wide. This is an ongoing evolving issue, so ild imagine that ALL game developers are aware of this and proceed with the game development concerning "rewards" with caution...

....the more you know 





In video games, a loot box (sometimes loot crate or prize crate, among other names) is a consumable virtual item which can be redeemed to receive a randomised selection of further virtual items, ranging from simple customization options for a player's avatar or character, to game-changing equipment such as weapons and armor. A loot box is typically a form of monetisation, with players either buying the boxes directly or receiving the boxes during play and later buying "keys" with which to redeem them. These systems may also be known as gacha (based on gashapon - capsule toys) and integrated into gacha games.
Loot box concepts originated from loot systems in massively multiplayer online role-playing games, and from the monetisation of free-to-play mobile gaming. They first appeared around 2007 to 2010, but since then, appear in many free-to-play games and in some full-priced titles. Loot box systems were made highly visible through the popularity of Overwatch (2016), but several games that followed in 2017 expanded approaches to loot boxes that caused loot box systems to be highly criticised by the second half of 2017, in particular Star Wars Battlefront II.
Loot boxes are regulated under gambling law in China, Japan, Australia, The Netherlands, Belgium, and the Isle of Man. They are the subject of investigations by the gambling regulators of several more countries. They have been criticised as being anti-consumer when implemented in full-priced games. They are a common source of the virtual items used in skin gambling.

Great read, I support this thread.
 
"Skin Gambling" refers to items that don't effect gameplay ...look that up, very interesting stuff concerning MMO-RPGs. Makes you realize there's so much more to game development than you'ld realize ...Venom was very inciteful with his thread about his time as an intern for a game developer if you haven't read his thread you should. It will give you insight to how game devs actually think and what motivates them to do what they do and how they do it.
 
China’s Loot Box Regulation 5/17

Last December, China’s Ministry of Culture released a new set of rules governing online games in the country, including a regulation that requires developers of video games that feature random loot boxes to reveal the odds of players receiving items. That rule, which officially took effect on March 1st, has led to multiple big-name companies revealing the drop rates for rare items in their loot boxes, many of them for the first time.
Daniel Ahmad, an analyst for Niko Partners, covered the new regulations when they were first released. As Ahmad summarizes, “Online game operators will need to disclose the name, property, content, quantity, and draw/forge probability of all virtual items and services that can be drawn/forge on the official game website or a dedicated draw probability webpage of the game.”
Some of the biggest games in the world, including Dota 2, League of Legends, Hearthstone, Heroes of the Storm, Overwatch, and Counter-Strike all rely on loot boxes as huge sources of income, given that many of the games are free-to-play titles. Instead of buying items or characters outright, players can play the game for free, but purchase mystery boxes that may or may not contain in-game items they want. It’s a bit like a slot machine, but where you put in real dollars to try to win virtual gear instead of money.
But given that players don’t know the actual odds behind the mystery prizes, buying them is essentially sinking money in a lottery, where players never know if the next box will contain common duplicates or that one rare skin they’ve been hunting for. Without the odds, there’s no way to really know how likely you are to get the item you want, something that even real cash lotteries are required to disclose. Players have tried in the past to work out loot box rates by collecting data from the gaming community, but the methodology only provided a rough guess for the actual rates. n response to the new regulation, several games have already released odds on treasure chests and loot boxes. Perfect World, Valve’s Chinese partner for Dota 2, announced its loot rates earlier this week, along with Riot, which has similarly released probabilities for loot and crafting in League of Legends. Other developers, including Blizzard, the publisher of the massively popular competitive shooter Overwatch, have yet to release any information on loot drops yet. That said, the Chinese regulation only requires developers to release rates for the Chinese version of a given game. So it’s entirely possible a developer could boost the drop rate in China, and release the numbers under the new rules, while offering far lower odds in the rest of the world.
Still, for players who feel like the odds are stacked against them when they open up their next loot box or card pack, the new regulations will at least give them some idea of just how bad their luck really is.
If anything, the data should be reason for other nations to consider similar laws to protect and inform players in games that increasingly rely on incentives similar to gambling.
 
In South Korea just few months ago...


South Korea fines game studios over deceptive loot box odds

5/18


The uproar over in-game loot boxes is leading to some real financial penalties -- in South Korea. The country's Fair Trade Commission has fined Nexon, Netmarble and NextFloor a total of 1 billion won (about $945,200) for allegedly deceptive loot box promotions. The regulator asserted that each of the studios either hid poor odds for obtaining in-game items with the purchases, or else advertised odds that were out of step with reality. Nexon didn't reveal that the chances of obtaining some in-game items in Sudden Attack (a popular first-person shooter) was just 0.5 percent, for example, while Netmarble's Monster Taming pitched odds of 1 percent for a key creature when the actual chance of winning was as low as 0.0005 percent.
The problem, of course, is that this can lead to some gamers spending inordinate amounts of money to get items that are far more elusive than they seem. In one case, the Commission noted that a Sudden Attack player spent about $430.
Not surprisingly, the companies aren't entirely happy. Nexon wants an "additional review" of the issue. Netmarble has apologized and made changes, but said it would "decide its response" after looking at the Commission's full decision.
While this case doesn't have much immediate bearing on other countries, it reflects the concerns many gamers and legislators have regarding loot boxes. They're worried that companies are overly dependent on loot boxes for profit, to the point where some titles base progression around them -- and more than a few people have described them as glorified gambling mechanisms. There might not be much of a need for fines elsewhere when some developers are already pulling these systems from their games, but the Korean action might hasten that retreat.
 
Belgian Gaming Commission rules some loot boxes are illegal gambling

4/18


Loot boxes in Counter-Strike: Global Offensive, Overwatch, and FIFA 18 are games of chance and do violate Belgian gambling regulations, the country’s Gaming Commission has declared. Their loot boxes will need to be removed, the Commission says, or the operators could face hefty fines and potentially prison time. This is a big development as governments view loot boxes and their ilk with an increasingly critical eye. The Commission started investigating loot boxes in four big games last year following Star Wars Battlefront II’s fiasco, though ironically Battlefront II is the only game whose loot boxes they deemed not gambling – after its recent changes, anyway.
The loot boxes must go from these three games, the Commission yesterday’s announcement (as I understand it through my rusty French, basically non-existent Dutch, and Google translation), and from any other games whose system qualifies as a game of chance. The Commission uses four parameters to identify a game of chance: having a game element, a bet that can lead to profit or loss and there’s an element of chance.
The games’ operators might also face prison sentences of up to five years and fines of up to €800,000 (£700k) – or double that amount if minors are involved. FIFA 18 has a PEGI age rating of 3 and Overwatch’s is 12, making them double-naughty, though CS:GO’s is 18.
The Gaming Commission don’t seem to be actually taking action yet, simply raising the possibility. I’m sure Valve, Activision, and EA will fight this tooth and nail.
Battlefront II is what kicked off this investigation but EA have reworked its loot boxes since then. While CS, Overwatch, and FIFA all sell loot boxes for money, in BF2 they’re now earned in-game by playing. The Commission are appeased by that change.
“Mixing games and gaming, especially at a young age, is dangerous for mental health,” Belgian minister of justice Koen Geens said in the announcement. “We have already taken numerous measures to protect both minors and adults against the influence of, among other things, gambling advertising. That is why we must also ensure that children and adults are not confronted with games of chance when they are looking for fun in a video game.”
Seems he wants to open a dialogue with developers, game operators, and the Commission to advance the discussion.
The Gaming Authority in the Netherlands also recently declared that some loot boxes in four out of ten (unnamed) games they examined were games of chance, and should be removed.
They didn’t object to all forms of loot boxes, only those whose items could be transferred, which they say gives items a market value. They reject the defence advanced by some that such loot boxes aren’t games of chance because they always give some item, never nothing. “This argument is not valid,” they said. “The in-game goods differ and have different market values if they can be traded. It is beyond doubt that the real winner is the person who wins the major, valuable prize with a high market value.”
Which, yeah, is a particular nuance that I’d not fully thought through myself. That is particularly a problem with PC gaming, where items from many games can be sold through the Steam Community Market (or sold for real cash, not store credit, through unofficial channels).
I still don’t expect widespread changes unless US authorities object (edit: or indeed the wider European Union, Alice you big doof). The Entertainment Software Rating Board, the North American industry’s self-policing ratings body, has rejected criticisms of loot boxes, though it has introduced vague labelling for game boxes to indicate in-game purchases. Some US senators are sniffing around loot boxes, prodding the ESRB for answers, but no firm action is underway yet.
 
....these "events" with the random drops. Well you see how as business practices these are viewed by regulatory of MANY countries.

It's seen by many as game developers "INCITING OR CREATING NEUROTIC BEHAVIOR SIMILAR TO THAT OF GAMBLING"

...again anyone who hasn't already read Venoms thread on working at one of these mmo game devs please do so.

Once you know the truth maybe just maybe you'll think twice....
 
I was wrong lol ...they will eventually regulate this in both the USA & GB

How the legal battle around loot boxes will change video games forever.

12/17



Hawaiian state representative Chris Lee recently held a press conference where he characterized loot boxes as “predatory gaming,” and is working on legislation to ban minors from buying them. He later added in a Reddit post that “these kinds of loot boxes and microtransactions are explicitly designed to prey upon and exploit human psychology in the same way casino games are so designed.” In Australia, a regulator for the state of Victoria agreed that “what occurs with ‘loot boxes’ does constitute gambling” and that the regulatory body for gaming was "engaging with interstate and international counterparts" on policy changes.


For years, microtransactions have become more and more prominent in gaming as a way of supplementing income for developers, or replacing the revenue gained by selling units — hence “free to play” games that are free to download and play, but make money by selling you small-ticket items or downloadable content in the game itself.
The unparalleled outcry from players, fans, press, and politicians about loot boxes in Star Wars Battlefront II signaled that we were at a breaking point. A flagship title of perhaps the world’s most profitable and famous IP was monetizing through microtransactions and loot boxes so pervasively that it felt openly exploitative. Every aspect of the game was now bent toward facilitating microtransactions. Characters or power-ups can take days worth of play to earn, which makes purchasing them in an in-game store more tempting.
A process that had begun over a decade ago has reached a crisis point. Loot boxes have brought the video game industry to a crossroads, and the path taken now will shape the future of the industry in profound ways. A process that had begun over a decade ago has reached a crisis point. Loot boxes have brought the video game industry to a crossroads, and the path taken now will shape the future of the industry in profound ways.
Whipple added, with deliberate clarity: “As close as I’m ever getting to giving actual legal advice to strangers on the internet who are not my clients is this: no, it does not have to be money. It has to be something of value, period.”
This discussion neatly lays out where the legal battle lines actually are. The issue has come up a handful of times in American courts, but the industry won those cases because digital objects were determined to have no value. In Whipple’s mind, this was because the judges were not “technologically literate,” and “did not understand what was going on,” instead seeing this very lucrative form of commerce as nothing more than “blips on a screen.”
The answer to this question — whether digital matter should be considered as real as what’s in your pocketbook
— affects every aspect of the tech industry. If the virtual is not real, rules are irrelevant; if it is, then we’re badly in need of a digital social contract. With the events of the last few years — from a president’s tweets moving markets, to discourse around online harassment
— we’re recognizing, slowly, that what happens online is, for all intents and purposes, real. We cannot simply switch it off.Pursuant to this specific discussion, the American legal framework on gambling is already primed to accept that. The legal test for gambling, here, never required actual currency to be won.
“Value doesn’t mean necessarily mean you like it and you want it. Value means it ‘has value.’” said Whipple. “If you can sell it to somebody, if you can transfer it to somebody...and exchange for some consideration, some payment, I would argue under that most gambling statutes that it is almost certainly something of value. If you can’t, that doesn’t mean it isn’t something of value, it just means it’d be harder to prove,”
The “harder to prove” bit is key, and that will be where the legal trenches are dug on this issue, I suspect. But it’s no guarantee of forestalling regulation and adverse judgements, and that’s equally critical to understand here.

The potential implications of this question are tremendous. They could theoretically categorize the entire business model of the popular deck-building game Magic: The Gathering’s as a form of gambling, along with numerous similar properties, and perhaps even the “blind boxes” of unknown minifigures sold by many tabletop RPG companies. That’s for courts and regulators to decide, of course. But the path is open now for major changes to the world of gaming.
What caused the game industry to charge so recklessly toward this precipice? Why risk doing something that would invite legal battles and government scrutiny above and beyond anything that the industry endured during the darkest days of the last generation’s culture wars? Inescapably, the answer is money.
A law review article in the aptly titled “Gaming Law Review” made that abundantly clear, with language that was unusually blunt for an academic paper. In her article “Skin Gambling: Have We Found the Millennial Goldmine or Imminent Trouble?” lawyer Desirée Martinelli analyses the legal landscape as relates to the practice of “skin gambling,” which is the practice of using skins — cosmetic alterations to in-game objects — as the ante for ever rarer ones. One report by the gambling industry analyst Chris Grove estimated that $7.4 billion worth of skins were wagered in 2016, with some significant percentage of that money undoubtedly going to the distribution platform Valve, which sold many skins in the first place.Valve has since pledged a crackdown on skin gambling, of course, but a broader issue remains: the mentality that let it flourish for so long in the first place.
Martinelli concludes that “the lack of regulation provides the perfect atmosphere for thirsty, tech-savvy entrepreneurs looking to capitalize on the craze” and that “courts may find it necessary to start reining in this millennial goldmine especially if a social policy concern such as underage gambling through e-sports and skins betting arises.”
The implications of this argument go far beyond skin gambling. The question of whether virtual goods have “real-world value” is central to a range of ethical questions about microtransactions, and is at the heart of the loot box question as well. In all cases, the motivation behind each mechanic is quite simply a yearning to make as much money as possible. There are practical reasons for this: blockbuster video games routinely cost tens of millions of dollars to make now, with costs continuing to rise.

It’s difficult to get sales figures on loot boxes by themselves, but they’re normally grouped into a bucket of controversial practices that are known in business jargon as “player recurring investment.” In other words, any penny made from something other than the initial cost of purchasing a game. This can be downloadable content (DLC), microtransactions as a whole, in-game advertising, subscription fees, and of course, loot boxes. As implied by the name, it’s money made from players who keep coming back to a game. Players “recur,” and the amount of time they spend in-game is more or less proportional to how much money they spend.
Ubisoft recently reported that for the first time, the company made more money from these microtransactions than it did from from digital sales of the games themselves. Not only that, but microtransaction sales had grown at a significantly faster rate than those overall unit sales compared to the previous year (83 percent compared to 57 percent).
More sensational individual stories have hit the wires as well. Kotaku interviewed a man who’d spent over $10,000 on microtransaction payments. In an interview with Waypoint, game developer Manveer Heir said that during his previous employment at BioWare, he had “seen people literally spend $15,000 on Mass Effect multiplayer cards." The reason, he said, was both profit and retention. Keep the players playing for longer, and thus paying for longer. The numbers, just from individuals, can be eye-watering.

But the entire lucrative enterprise depends on these goods being categorized as “not real” or having “no value.” This is, unsurprisingly, the mindset of game developers at large, and it’s supported by at least a few regulators worldwide. The New Zealand Department of Interior Affairs, which oversees its gambling licensing, told me that it “is of the view that loot boxes do not meet the legal definition of gambling.” The Australian state of Queensland, meanwhile, disagreed with its southern counterpart in Victoria on the question. At the heart of such opinions is whether virtual loot is real and valuable.
Tim Miller, the executive director of the UK Gambling Commission, reinforced that point in an interview with Eurogamer’s Vic Hood, emphasizing that he doesn’t believe loot box proceeds are “valuable” — an opinion that could transform the future of gaming. If they are deemed “valuable,” mechanics strewn through countless games on every platform, might end up being criminalized or strictly regulated in the US and abroad. Regulators could raise questions about card games and tabletop role-playing games that bank on similar mechanics with much tighter profit margins.
The recent statements from gambling regulators and legislators worldwide constitute an opening shot in the battle over loot boxes, not a climax. The industry’s biggest players are unlikely to give up a multibillion-dollar revenue stream without a fight. But the stakes are larger than even that princely sum. This is a battle for the soul of gaming; we’re at a crossroads where the industry has to choose who and what it wants to be.The loot boxes of Battlefront II seemed to presage an industry that produced lavish video lottery machines, where all art had been sublimated into mere backdrops for mechanics whose sole purpose was the extraction of maximum profit. The gaming industry has been on the cusp of a digital nightmare where games and their stories were tailored around profitable systems, not the other way around. Thanks to this controversy, it has a chance to take a different path now.
Loot boxes are only one kind of microtransaction, but they’re often discussed as a unit because all microtransactions rely on similarly seductive sales techniques. They also permit theoretically unlimited revenue to be drawn from a game. Cajoling and enticing players onto that limitless funicular track of spending raises serious ethical issues, especially where our youngest players are involved.
Because of the moral panics that have been weaponized against everything from Dungeons & Dragons to Grand Theft Auto in the past, everyone who works in or around the gaming industry has a certain, marrow-deep revulsion to arguments that smack of “what about the children!?” But children aren’t the only ones harmed by a gambling economy; their cases are just especially egregious. It is long past time to stop reliving the culture wars of the last three decades and move on. Many of the people complaining about loot boxes now are the very same people who play and adore games, not right-wing religious extremists who want to obliterate everything we love.

Seeking to ban a specific revenue-generating practice that is inessential to artistic expression is very different from banning games on the basis of content — or banning them altogether. If we can have the debate on those terms, rather than the apocalyptic ones we’ve been saddled with, something good might come out of this whole mess.
The future could still be one in which we — consumers, regulators, developers, and critics — develop an entirely new ethical framework around microtransaction economies and the sale of digital content. Perhaps it will require government intervention, or perhaps it’ll take the form of industry self-regulation. Either way, the industry could come out the other side of this acrimonious debate, and its forthcoming legal battles, not just intact, but better than it was before.
 
If any VK and or Mods come on this thread being all combative,off topic, and or crappy towards the op will be asked to leave as per forum tou.

I support this thread.
 
I think it's funny how all the dev (establishment) supporters are staying away from this thread.

...everything that's been said in this thread in quotes are the exact same things I've been saying for years now. Two months after HTE came out when Apoc v ZAFT 2 broke out I stated most of this in the thread dedicated to that OSW I said almost verbatim about how devs incite and encourage neurotic behavior among its player base to generate in game purchases and that was way before they even started running events. I said it again when they did start running events with chest drops.

...I was called lunatic hater idk how many times. Where all you people now? Doesn't look like your willing to defend your position anymore ...i.e.: that devs have your best interest in mind/heart and that this is all about "KAWmunity" ....read the thread and still tell me that. Expose yourselves for what you really think.


Hey if I'm wrong come prove it...

Everything I quoted is all over the Internet
 
I've been dealing a lot with securities laws lately for work, and gaming is an area I can't say I'm surprised is getting a whip crack at the moment.

I'm a proponent for odds-of-draw display on anything and everything. But be warned, that approach only adds to the addictive tendencies for some.

I agree it needs to be regulated,but defining it by value is, in my opinion, far too vague.

Transferability
Sellability (to the first consumer)
Secondary market presence

For all intents and purposes, things like generic ice and non-specific dirt have value under those tests, but it seems silly that someone would make the market for ice and dirt.

Any digital asset has innate value when considering gaming - perhaps it alters the appearance, maybe it impacts playability, maybe it gives small stat bonuses.

Meanwhile, if MTG were to publish card draw rates, the secondary and tertiary markets could potentially estabilsh a rarity-only based pricing model, completely defeating the purpose of the innate value of a card.

What do you guys think?

I would be fond of seeing drop rates for KaW boxes.
 
I would love to see drop rates too...

It's needed. Some method of measure has to be established to hold devs accountable. As to date all we get are dev support posts from VK/Mods saying their fixing things when they're obviously not.

And there has been issues with drops from events in the past ....yes I agree some accountability would be nice. People spend money on this thing ...I used to. We have to be treated like consumers and have the rights of consumers ....been saying this for a long time now. RL world has caught on ....sorry this little matrix is being blown apart.

~Morpheous
 
This was from one of the early events maybe the second one dated over 3 years ago.....

Notice how two people (both adults I might add) encouraging neurotic behavior ....go through the thread see what else ev1 else had to say about it






 
....the one thing I was wrong about was I said it wasn't as bad as being hooked on drugs or gambling


I was wrong ...it's the same thing

Not trolling read this thread the regulatory of many many countries have come to this same conclusion and are inacting legislation to regulate.
 
Your_Karma_Bill_Is_Due_Nooblet said:
Coupled with a little self-control and Common Sense, even with or without posted odds you wouldn't need to take a second mortgage out for a video game.


All gambling is regulated Karma ....$1 scratch off tickets are regulated.

A .25 cent slot machine is regulated.


Both of these have ruined lives ....ild agree with what you said about self control and restraint though ....I appreciate your conservative viewpoint on the matter, thanks for posting
 
Back
Top