hatf1eld said:Thanks Devs. This is helpful data but want to point out a couple things that will hopefully help you going forward:
1. It has always been my observation that you have placed far too much emphasis on raw stats and not nearly enough on bfa. Having said this, I believe with the introduction of new lands and buildings it has helped reflect in raw stats, what was once a bfa difference. So therefore your algorithm can be more effective as bfa has effectively been converted to new lands and buildings. I would highly recommend introducing hf build upgrades as soon as possible as this will further serve to distinguish the conversion of bfa to raw stats and therefore help with better matchups.
2. I couldn't disagree more with the standard/no advantage KO setup. This has a few negative effects such as: (1) gives the 'losing side' very little chance to get back into the war because the opposition knows exactly when their shadow will appear at the doorstep and have 15 guns aiming at their heads-no chance. (2) it places a ridiculous burden on clans to find trackers whose only job is to sit and watch cc for the reds and constantly update their spreadsheet. It's overkill and frankly nobody should spend that much time on a game-especially if these wars will be the setup for season 2. 15-20 wars in a week....good luck keeping people on kaw for the long haul because you will have tremendous burnout and people will just quit warring and/or quit kaw altogether.
3. Place more emphasis on bfa. While I think introducing the upgrades on hf ASAP will mitigate some of this distortion, I still think you need to weigh more heavily the bfa of warriors when creating matchup. To me I never understood why you made this so complicated....you should just add up raw stats, bfa, bfe and get a sum of this. Maybe even the average or median as a means for you to create good matchups.
4. Come out much earlier than 20 hours before first war with war times. People have been preparing since Monday and using the times from last week as a basis for preparing rosters.
5. I agree with er-rudimentary that you will most certainly see larger gaps in plunder this war as a result of the standard 10 minute KO time.
That's all I can think of for now but we do appreciate the transparency and insight into the statistics. And we appreciate your willingness to listen.
I agree with everything hatf1eld and and would like to emphsize on the advantage ko system, that was the best change in these test wars and it would be a damn shame if you decide to leave it out of next season.