Oh Devs....you guys are missing the point. The plunder graphs you have provided don't really provide match up clarity at all. Plunder variance reflects the winners of wars, not the match up accuracy. The Random regen times allowed mismatches to minimize the plunder gaps . It certainly is not a reflection of the match up system.
An example for you,one of many, Week 9, War 6.
CS: Warlor- 162/175/25/100(m), Us= 148/155/38/92(m). Yes, 100% of Warlor could hit Us, and 100% of Us could hit them-so matched well in DTW/DTS.
BFE: All but nine players that war had ample full enchanted mith /season 1 Rancor equipment. BFA: They had Allie LB 9,34, and 177. We had 53,132, and 199. Final Plunder score: 30 B vs 86 B.
Sure hit ratio looked great, plunder gap was 'reasonable'...but I definitely would not call it a 'war', it was more like 'attempted survival.' The key Word being 'attempted'....no matter what strategy was employed, it would not have made a difference in that war. Warlor is a respected seasoned EE clan.
Fewer clans sign up for war week over week, so the pool of potential match-ups are becoming limited. I don't claim to know the answer to that, but perhaps everyone who wars should receive a level of EE, and increase the winning sides mith payout for reward? All I know, is that something is going to have to change soon, or you will continue to lose clans that are trying to participate in EE that couldn't participate in Season one. We don't want an easy war by any means, we just want a chance.
Now, perhaps you have a pretty graph for that?