KaW_admin,
After looking over the limited data you have released, I have a few observations or questions (some of which have been expressed above, but I reiterate them nonetheless).
(1) In the last two weeks you indicate you believe there has been a reduction in the number of blowouts. However, before we can conclude that there is a coorelation between the reduction in blowouts and the changes made recently, can you provide information as to the changes that were made between weeks 5-7 and weeks 8-9? For example, it goes without saying that a shorter war will, by definition, result in a smaller plunder difference as there is less time for the prevailing team to build up a lead (and the use of percentages rather than raw numbers does not make this less true if you are using statistical regression analysis). For example, and using only the KO system as a discussion point, if you can turtle, the plunder difference will be smaller, even if you are being sat on by a stronger team--that does not mean it is a better matchup, it simply means the Random/Advantage system gives the party who has been KO'd the opportunity to pop up and self KO before the attacker can reasonably be expected to hit them--thus tightening the plunder differences, but not necessarily meaning the matchup itself was more equal.
(2) For what it's worth, I don't think the KaW community will ever be a consensus on Random/Advantage KO times versus set KO times. People have different reasons for favoring one system over the other. People who hate spamming targets for up to 5 minutes will never see eye to eye with people who equally dislike being KO'd the moment the come up from KO in a set system. Many people have suggested a 15 minute KO with up to 2 minute advantage/random window in order to give a little to each side. Just a thought.
(3) WIth respect to the issue of DTW/DTS--I tend to agree with the people who say remove it from the actual gameplay (even if you retain it in the matchup system). As I understand it, your rationale seems to be that the matchup will be fairer if a LB player will be prevented from hitting a smaller player--but in reality the LB player would never waste his/her attacks on smaller players when plunder is the name of the game. The LB player will concentrate on the top 4-5 people from the opposing clan and simply decimate them. At the other end of the scale, weaker players generally do not try to hit the top of the clan, but will concentrate on the middle where their equipment bonuses make it more likely that they will succeed in their attacks. Consequently, it is the middle of the clan that can be hit by all players from the other side, and that is like being in a meat grinder. Therefore, in order to counter this problem, man clans employ their middles to "take out the high and low ends" so to speak. This leaves the LB players at the top and the GH players at the bottom waving at each other and waiting for a kingdom in the middle to pop up so they can crush it. That sucks for the middle players. So if you insist on keeping DTW/DTS as part of the mechanic, I would suggest only having it as part of the matchmaking mechanic, but not the actual war itself.
I'm sure other thoughts will follow as more people express their opinions. Thanks for trying to make the system better.
Cheers,
Kage.