Versus

Basically, this is creating a scenario where two video game, movie, or comic book characters fight.

You have to create a scenario where they are both on equal ground. They must also have accurate weapons to their character. Batman can't have an Uzi. I know, tragic.

The person below you can answer who they think would win, and why, as well as their own scenario.

I have two.

First fight

The first one is: John Marston vs Max Payne

Little backstory, John Marston is the star of the critically acclaimed video game by rockstar called Red Dead Redemption, which takes place in an open world old west environment. Marston is a former outlaw, who is tasked with hunting down his former gang members, and he is six kinds of awesome. John Marston is a dead shot, and the video game also has a feature Called "Dead Eye" that allows you to slow down time and select your targets.
Dead Eye level one in the game only allows you to slow down time and fire, as the other levels allow you to 'paint' targets. We'll give John Dead Eye Lvl. 1, making him equal to Payne.

Pros:
- Dead shot
- Lightning Fast Reflexes

Cons: Much of his weaponry is inferior to Payne's, although this is a small matter. If John can get off a shot, at the right time, he'll win.

Max Payne is the star of the videogame... Max Payne. 1, 2, and 3. Also by Rockstar games.
He is a tough as nails cop, who's wife and baby were killed in a home breaking incident.
His game has a feature where you can see time slower, and dive to the side while shooting to avoid gunfire.

Pros:
- He is a cop with weapons training
- He has no problem with fighting dirty

Cons:
- During the events of !ax Payne 3, he is an Alcoholic, which could or could not effect his performance (pun pun pun)

Now, to the fight.

They are in a two storey warehouse. The warehouse is littered with crates, shelves and boxes, making for easy cover, but there are large open spaces as well.

The stairway is near the back of the warehouse.

John Marston starts on the top storey with:
His Colt Peacemaker Revolver and 18 Rounds
- Remington Repeater and 20 Rounds
- The Explosive Rifle and 1 Round
- A Shotgun and 10 Rounds
- A Colt 1911 Pistol and One Extra Magazine
- His Lasso
- And 5 Molotov Coctails

Max starts on the first floor with:
- A Desert Eagle and One Extra Magazine
- Colt M1 Assault Rifle and 30 Rounds
- A Spas Riot Shotgun and 10 Rounds
- A Grenade Launcher and 1 Round
- A Berreta 9mm Pistol and One Extra Magazine
- And Five Grenades

Their ammo is about the same, and their weapons are close as well.
The odds are even.

Who do you think would win?

As much as I like John Marston, I can't help but feel Max would win. Even with John's aim, Max Payne took down whole corporations and armies.

Second fight

Jason Bourne vs Ethan Hunt

Jason Bourne is a super spy with slightly enhanced physical abilities, as a result of being a CIA agent and Test Subject.
He is an expert in hand to hand fighting, as well as many types of weaponry. Jeremy Renner has been the star in a Bourne film.

Pro's:
- Advanced Martial Arts Training
- Expert with all types of weaponry
- Able to easily blend in in a public environment

Cons:
- Dude falls on his face, like all the time.
- He gets painful headaches.

Ethan Hunt is the star of the Mission Impossible Movie series. He is a shadow agent of the IMF, and he can operate invisible in a public environment for extended periods of time.
He is a technical expert, hand to hand expert, and is proficient with most weaponry.
He can also run really fast, and coincidentally, Jeremy Renner is a main character too.

Pro's:
- IMF Superspy
- Hand to hand fighting expert
- Proficient with almost all forms of weaponry
- He has a whole friggin team to back him up if need be

Cons:
- He has been known to get overconfident
-
They start in the same warehouse.

Jason is on the top floor with:
- A Glock Handgun with a Silencer and One Extra Magazine
- A SCAR-H Assault Rifle and Two Extra Magazines
- A .357 Magnum Revolver with 12 Rounds

Ethan is on the bottom floor with:
- A Springfield 9mm Handgun with one Extra Magazine
- An ACR Rifle and Two Extra Magazines
- A .44 Magnum Revolver with 12 Rounds.


You decide the winners.

 

Indeed.