I know the devs are working to improve upon the player vs player experience and rewards so I thought that implementing the Estoc's Edge bonus in player battles makes perfect sense. Estoc's Edge was created to promote wars and reward those fortunate victors. Another of its main purposes was to "improve clan unity" by penalizing those who left the clan by losing one level of EE (this didn't work out so the devs removed this penalty). Seeing that EE is won through PvP (Rancor Wars) yet only gives bonuses towards EB's, it is actually discouraging the PvP aspect of the game. When a player has reached level 5 EE and getting full bonus on Smoke Signals.. they are more likely making a lot more gold than they would fighting a similar size foe and not to mention they are probably not using pots. This could also improve clan unity, as was one of its original purposes, by encouraging more osw. It just seems logical that a bonus won from PvP should reward PvP actions, especially if the devs will be implementing pot drops and other things to enhance the system. Just my thoughts, but hey what do I know?