EDIT July 31st: War idea is now for future wars now that S5 is released. Thx My War idea is a lil radical... CS BFA BFE on 2 week segments Playoffs on 2nd weekend Each segment winner is in Season Finals More segments the bigger the Finals PLAYOFF FORMAT: Round Robin 2 best records go to Finals for better rewards Tiebreaker is total plunder Top 4 WC's n 96 warriors in each tier receive playoff bonus rewards. WC's chosen is Won/Lost record. Tiebreaker is total plunder Warriors chosen by combined actions n defensive fails. ENTRY: WC's cast a special WOC spell min 1hr early n chosen by the Devs Warriors cast as above also n go into a pool ranked Hi/LO incl CS BFA BFE Xtal to enter war n given a War regen spell only used for war n expires if unused. Current war rewards for EE r same n can win back xtals. WC's r placed into tiers n draft a roster of 20-25 out of their tier. Eg draft friends. War clans can submit a roster 1 1/2hr prior to war n SS posted immediately. Roster can drop to to as low as 20 if insufficient WOC sign ups to balance out War clans designate 5 warriors to be dropped if needed to match equally. If ur not selected or placed oh well try again DRAFT: 1/2 hr draft period or autofill kicks on n everyone LIVES with the matchup. 1/2hr wait til war starts. KaW generates an SS for all clans. WC is turned off WC can silence cc spammers sabotage Rough draft idea n feel free to adjust it. Ignore the usual trollers derailing. Nothing is in stone n open to constructive criticism if helpful. Its not a support or no support thread. Looking for a proactive war format only. Ty EDIT: 10:59am PDT This proposal allows an element that allows war clans n quasi Indi clans both to co-participate. 11:46am PDT Stay tuned as i will update your tweaks if improves the basic S5 Proposal. 12:31pm PDT LB/SH rosters r matched up against each other. Odd clan out gets NM 3:22pm PDT See edit below to mitigate LB/SH rosters 3:14pm PDT To mitigate LB/SH rosters say a gap of eg 15-25m cs to be included for a valid War Clan roster. Spy builds to be x 1.5 to give a truer cs. Eg 60m cs Hansel is 90m cs actually
One flaw u might see is exploit rosters can still be entered. I don't have a solution for that but others might have ideas that can solve it. With Clan rosters submitted 1.5hrs early n an SS generated it leaves time for ppl to choose to enter or not after looking at entrants. No guarantee to be matched against an exploit roster but the chance is there. Ur welcome to help improve this proposal
Lol funny how people who don't war say no But idea can work but at this rate we still have few more events till s5 if it happens.
Not necessarily... Tiering spreads out builds n helps avoid very uneven rosters. Similar to IWar generated rosters now. WC's take turns drafting. Thats the idea anyways. Thx for input
Agreed plus support. One suggestion is tracker also is assigned. In classic wars they are vital to a win
Works for me but how to define who is a tracker so as devs can spread around the clans? We all know our WC's n Trackers in our current tiers. Q is how do the devs know n can implement those that r WC's n Trackers.
I do like the suggested s5 proposal. Very well thought out. I would definitely like to see this and not just cause I want s5 here like yesterday.
Its intended to offer something for everyone. I'm sure more ppl have more to add to improve it n get it to a final proposal. Thx TG
If this proposal gets serious traction can we request a trial in preseason? That is after all ppl input helpful tweaks.
As for the trackers, I'll need to think this one out. Having a opt in for trackers causes 2 concerns for me: 1. Too many cast not all will be assigned 2. Some may cast that have no experience and may sabotage the war being so. This is where a spell would been handy in earlier stages of kaw that carried stats in wins/losses for wc and trackers which it shown experience let alone how many wars these positions have been used by the player. I post my war stats update proposal later on to reflect.