This is easy. Make everything % based. But not just equip (no way this would happen anyway) like others have suggested, but Mith spells and Pots, too. Short and sweet. Nothing else to it, just some food for thought.
While I honor what you are trying to acomplish with this thread getting rid of Sh will not get rid of the spy exploit. People will just exploit with the nxt spy building which I believe is volaries. If we don't learn from history it's doomed to repeat itself. Remember when guild hansels were nerfed?
Be careful what you wish for, if you think war with sh is unfavorable, wait until clans move to pure spy and lb because sh dies. Never under estimate peoples desire to win.
Yes but bigs should be matched with bigs, and ps should be matched with ps. Just that the matching system is not perfected. Yet.